Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Citizen Critic

1.     1. Donald Lazere in ”Reading and Writing for Civic Literacy: A Critical Citizen’s Guide” chapter 5 he discusses viewpoint, bias and fairness of a citizen critic. He gives his main ideas of what it means to be fair and what he thinks works best in being a citizen critic and what doesn’t. Lazere shares many of the same ideas that Edward Corbett and Rosa Eberly shared in their “The Elements of Reasoning.” They have similar ideas and some of them are the same. They both talk about the term “false dilemma” and how it affects becoming a citizen critic. Corbett and Eberly defines false dilemma as something that “forces a range of choices into an either/or structure” (pg. 128). Another viewpoint they have in common is “straw man.” Corbet and Eberly define straw man as something that “involves exaggerating your opponent’s position and the representing that exaggeration as his position” (pg. 130).  They both discus personal attacks as well. Instead of discussing an issue, they instead decide to attack the person that represents or supports the issue that they are against. Lazere refers to it as an ad hominem. All of these are diversions of reasoning. They are ways the “examining and critiquing the reasoning of others…” (pg.124). These ideas are put to work in Jamelle Bouie’s article “White People are Fine with Laws that Harm Blacks.” He uses the straw man fallacy to make strong points against his opponents by taking the worst thing he can use from his opponents and making it the only thing heard or remembered.  He uses false dilemma by only giving the people he interviewed a yes or no option after a short video. The solution to his problem is greater than just one question with two simple answers. He kind of uses personal attacks in his title by saying that white people are okay with harming black people instead of addressing the issue that black people are treated unfairly.
3.    3.  In “I agree, but..” McDonald used the idea of agreeing with what the opponent says but also showing them why it isn’t a good enough answer to the problem (pg. 206) He makes it a point that it isn’t good to only give reasons why you are right because your opponent will find a way to shoot you down. Lazere mentions that “stacking the deck” in your favor isn’t productive because your opponent wont listen to what you have to say if your point only talks about your ideas.  Bouie kind of stacks the deck in his favor and only shows us how his ideas are right and that white people are wrong. It doesn’t help his argument because that comes off as biased and people might get frustrated and not want to read it anymore.  
4.      



Thursday, October 9, 2014

The Rhetoric of Social Websites

In The Multimediated Rhetoric of the Internet, Carolyn Handa brings us through a study that discusses how websites are used for rhetorical performances that socially impact our lives and our world.  She explains that social sites aren’t always what we think that they are. Its common to think of a social site as a means of communication like Twitter or Facebook but it can be as simple as a site that connects a community together (Handa p.117).  As long as a site impacts a community then it can be considered a social site.  Handa also states, “…the importance of staying ahead in the competitive world of technology, and the importance of making education relevant to minority students…” are two exigent circumstances of rhetoric (Handa p. 118). She brought up a website that the Southern Illinois University, Edwardsville has to help explain her ideas.

The SIUE has a Black Studies Program which ahs a website. The point of the website is to create a place for African American studies to communicate in order for the to get more involved and stay in school. According to many studies, “African American students have fewer retention rates than their white counterparts” (Handa p. 142). This website makes sense as a rhetorical exigence because as M. Jimmie Killingworth stated in Appeals to Time, an “exigence suggests that topics emerge as urgent considerations at a particular historical time” (p.38). At this point in time the retention rate of African American students is a problem so a website dedicated to getting them more involved will give them the motivation to stay in school instead of dropping out.

Handa describes that there was urgency in exigence but also that there was kairos, which is another rhetorical concept. According to Killingsworth, kairos is “finding the right argument at the right moment” (p. 38).  The argument that Handa talks about is the retention rate of African American students compared to white students in our universities at this time.  It is a situation that needs to be fixed so they used a website as a rhetorical performance to try to raise the retention rates.  

The website is designed to show the ethos, pathos and logos of the rhetorical situation. They used the Black Power fist on their page in order to gain some emotional response from the students to make them realize that getting involved in things on the website will make them stronger and able to succeed. They used different things from the African American culture that would really stand out on their page to give them a place that they felt as if they belonged more, which is an emotional stance.  It also has a blog for people to communicate making it a modern space for students in the now to be able to use it to their advantage.  It uses the appeals of time by Killingsworth by using epideictic speech, or present day known as instructions, to point students in the right direction based on what is happening now.


The site uses advertising in order to tell students what opportunities there are to get involved in now. Killingsworth states, “The aim is to move consumers to buy new products. The idea of progress, with the suggestion that technology…continuously improves the conditions of human life…” (p. 40). Handa and Killingsworth both argue how important technology can be in our lives and how much it can impact how successful our lives can be. I think that as much as technology has taken over our lives it can also be a huge benefit if it is used in a positive way instead of just sitting on Facebook or Twitter all day. People look at social sites as distracting but if they view a social site as a website like a university site, it is a way to communicate and get involved. As long as it is set up well then it will be beneficial.

Tuesday, September 30, 2014

I Agree, But...I Disagree.."

In “I Agree, But…” James McDonald describes citizenship, as “individuals become citizens by discursively- and thus rhetorically-engaging one another in the public sphere. “ Its a way for people to share their viewpoints or concerns for an issue with people that may disagree with them.  He also describes public deliberation, as “citizens who have opposing views on issues can explain the foundations of their beliefs.” He doesn’t stop there though. He uses public deliberation as a way to discuss an issue and come up with new ways to solve a problem by allowing the two parties discussing the issue to understand each other’s ideas more and come up with a new solution that maybe isn’t so black and white.  McDonald uses the Le Suroit case to describe his versions of deliberation and citizenship because it was a case study that showed them pretty brilliantly. Le Suroit is a sociotechnical controversy in Canada revolving around whether or not they should allow The Suroit natural gas-fired electrical plant to be constructed.

McDonald shows how the pro-Suroit supporters and the anti-Suroit supporters used rhetorical situations in their arguments to get their adversaries to understand where they are coming from and to keep them from knocking down their major points.  He explains that the best way to approach a situation in an argument is to accept some of the opinions of your opponent while still making it clear that you disagree overall on the situation. This helps to come up with an overall solution knowing that both parties can agree on something and it also keeps your opponent from going on and on about their ideas.  For example, in the Le Suroit controversy, when discussing alternatives, the pro-Suroit supporters made it a point to say that they were already supporters of wind energy but that it was an unreliable source, which in turn made the anti-Suroit supporters in need of a new argument.

David Kaufer has own way to deliberate public policy. He first mentions stock issues and that they, “aid invention by helping speakers single out from the list of stock issues those obtaining in the immediate case; aid organization by insure speakers against omitting information; aid adaptation of speech to audiences by guiding speakers to include points the audiences expect them to address.”  He has created five different hierarchical levels of policy conflict: level one, one of us misunderstands the intended sense or reference of certain statements; level two, we misunderstand each other’s intended frame of reference in making certain statements; level three, we each give decisive weight to different evidence; level four, we hold conflicting local values (values people hold about specific topics); and level five, we hold conflicting global values (values people hold systematically across topics and contexts). He explains that you start with level one and work your way up to five until you have fully resolved the issue at hand.

Kaufer uses the example of the drinking age (18 vs 21). Usually people have equally worthy points and since those points will never override one or the other, he uses a similar idea to McDonald. Kaufer uses a similar idea to teen drinking being a responsibility like driving and makes them both into a positive. He also shows the negative point and compares the teen drinking to drag races.


Kaufer combines his stock issues with his new five level theory of policy conflict to teach students the most efficient way to argue a situation. The five level theory gives the students the opportunity to create a more creative solution to the problem by having to work through a few levels to see the most beneficial outcome to a problem. The stock issues alone don’t do that. Just as Kaufer has his five level theory, McDonald uses his rhetorical practice to of agreeing to key opinions to show people how efficiently that works. He shows that just saying “you’re wrong,” doesn’t have the same affect as saying “I understand your point, but…” or “I understand my flaws, but…” because those two statements will stop the opponent from pointing our your flaws if you do so yourself already. Then, your opponents will need to come up with a new strategy to make your argument weaker. McDonald’s “accepting key ideas” is similar to Kaufer’s level 5 of his levels of policy conflict. They both agree to disagree and know that one wont win over the other necessarily but they find a new way to come up with a solution that they may both agree on partially.

Thursday, September 25, 2014

Is Technology Helping or Hurting the Minds of America's Youth?

People have discussed for ages the benefits of using longhand versus laptops in a classroom. Pam A. Mueller and Daniel M. Oppenheimer have done studies to try to the answer the question of, what is better? In The Pen is Mightier Than The Keyboard Mueller and Oppenheimer conduct three different studies that all conclude that in conceptual tests, people who have taken notes longhand have done significantly better than people who have taken notes on their laptops.

The question has always been, what is the more efficient way to take notes in order for students to do the best they can on a test? Longhand or on laptops? The real question is, how is technology affecting the students’ education? Is it helping or hurting the minds of our nation’s youth.

Some high school teachers feel as if technology is ruining the education system and the creativity of the students. Valerie Strauss, a writer for The Washington Post, shared a resignation letter that a tenured teacher, Gerald Conti, wrote to the superintendent of Westhill High school in Syracuse, NY. Conti had been teaching at Weshtill for over twenty years before he decided to resign. He felt that the education system was relying way too much on technology and that the Board of Education for Westhill has “distrust, dictating that teachers cannot be permitted to develop and administer their own quizzes and tests (now titled as generic “assessments”) or grade their own students’ examinations. “ Not only does Conti feel mistrusted to do his job he also feels like the creativity of the students is being limited by online classes and work. “This approach not only strangles creativity, it smothers the development of critical thinking in our students and assumes a one-size-fits-all mentality more appropriate to the assembly line than to the classroom. “

If Mueller and Oppenheimer’s results show that students perform significantly worse while using computers to take notes and Gerald Conti says that computers “smother critical thinking,” is it possibly that using a laptop in educational settings may not be as beneficial as educations had originally thought that it would be? There ideas together seem to answer the initial question of is technology helping or hurting the minds of our nation’s youth. Students don’t seem to perform as well with the media aspects in school probably because they are testing it on a generation that grew up learning off a blackboard or a dry erase board instead of a computer.  Online classes aren’t as common in high school but they are starting to take tests and do more things online that weren’t done before. Even though the results don’t seem to be where researchers want them, is it necessary for teachers to start using more computers based classes in high school to prepare their students for online college courses?

Many college courses are available online. Students take them because they generally seem easier to pass but are they learning from them or just receiving an A in the class? Bernard Schweizer is a tenured professor at Duke University. He enrolled in a MOOC (Massive Open Online Course). In Confessions of an Unreconstructed MOOC(h)her he describes how the class works. He states that 60,000 kids can take this course and that they readings and video lectures are optional for the students. That shows that it isn’t all about learning, its all about how well you can do an assignment with putting in as little work as possible.  The class is graded by peer reviews, which doesn’t give the student the satisfaction of hearing back from a teacher why they did or didn’t pass an assignment. Online classes like MOOC make the possibility of cheating or plagiarism jump as well since students can work next to each other on their computers to complete assignments and test.

Mueller and Oppenheimer’s proved that laptop use to take notes isn’t incredibly affective so if that is put with Schweizer’s perspective of an online MOOC class with unlimited participation based on peer reviews, how is that an affective learning environment for college students? Student-teacher interaction is a big deal for many students whether they realize it or not; it makes the learning process more engaging and sitting through a class versus taking a class online could help improve test scores since people aren’t skipping around just to find answers to questions.

Without a doubt, the technology that has been brought into the classrooms with computers is absolutely mind-blowing but the question still stands, is technology helping or hurting the youth of our nation?


http://jordyherbst.blogspot.com/p/jordan-herbst-enc4404-september-252014.html


Tuesday, September 23, 2014

The Importance of Written Communication in the Workforce

In a report by The National Commission on Writing it was state that “Writing is a ‘threshold skill’ for salaried employment and promotion” (Bob Kerrey). People don’t keep into consideration the importance of writing in our everyday lives. Even if you are in a math or science field you still have to be able to write up reports or emails to your supervisor or employees.  It isn’t just employees on a salary that writing is a big deal but it is also commonly used in hourly employees. Why is writing such a big deal? How does it affect our future?

Most communication in the workforce is through writing since people are often too busy to have a meeting or if they do have a meeting or an oral presentation is it generally accompanied by a visual presentation (PowerPoint) that involves writing in some way. Without the ability to write how does one report back to their boss or express their ideas for many people to see?

In Jeanne Fahnestock’s article Accommodating Science: The Rhetorical Life of Scientific facts, we see that writing is important in every aspect of life. Without people having writing skills we wouldn’t be able to read the words of Einstein or read past scientific documents to help us improve as much as we have in the past 15 years in science.  “A teleological argument claims that something has value because it leads to further benefits” (Jeanne Fahnestock).  Without the abilitity to write their findings, a scientists work wouldn’t matter because people wouldn’t be able to look back on it to use it in future studies.

In M. Jimmie Killingsworth and Jacqueline S. Palmer's journal Ecospeak: Rhetoric and Environmental politics in America they mention that "A third group of writings is called "articles"; these are written by noted specialists in the field..." It is obviously important that the science specialists can write their findings down because if they trusted someone else to do their writing for them, there could end up being a mistake in their article which would give future researchers false information to go off of.

Written communication is a skill that everyone should possess, not just people in the science field. It is important for a person's ideas to be shared and read by many in order for history to be made or things like advancements in science to be made.